The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Francis McGuinness on a limited point about a spoken conviction in the Circuit Court. It granted him leave on 17 December 2024. Charleton J., Hogan J. and Donnelly J. made the determination.
The panel said there had been "an unhappy history to the procedural journey of this case through the Circuit Court".
Mr McGuinness was convicted in the District Court on 29 January 2018 of driving without a licence and without insurance. He was fined and disqualified from driving for three years. He appealed to the Circuit Court.
On 9 July 2019, the Circuit Court judge said she was satisfied he was not insured and was "going to convict". No formal order followed, and the judge has since retired.
Mr McGuinness took judicial review proceedings. The High Court refused leave on 23 May 2023. The Court of Appeal upheld that on 6 June 2024. It held that the judge's indication of guilt had no binding effect without a formal order, and that his appeal should be reheard by another Circuit Court judge.
The Supreme Court said the status of an orally pronounced conviction by a Circuit Court judge hearing an appeal is a matter of public importance. It raises the question of whether he has already been convicted and should not be tried again. The panel also found that an appeal is in the interests of justice on that point.
Leave covers only the grounds set out in the determination. The court directed him to file a draft amended statement of grounds dealing exclusively with that issue.