localnews.ie

Garrett Smith refused Supreme Court appeal over 14½-year manslaughter sentence

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had already rejected his appeal against the severity of the sentence, imposed after a jury acquitted him of murder.

Garrett Smith has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against the severity of his sentence for manslaughter. O'Malley J., Murray J. and Collins J. gave the determination on 13 December 2024. The Court of Appeal had dismissed his appeal on 4 July 2024.

A Central Criminal Court jury acquitted Mr Smith of murder but convicted him of manslaughter and violent disorder. He was sentenced to fourteen and a half years for manslaughter, with the final year suspended.

For violent disorder he received six years, to run concurrently. The trial judge nominated a headline sentence of 16 years for the manslaughter.

He allowed a 10% deduction for Mr Smith's offer to plead guilty to manslaughter, which the prosecution did not accept. A further 18 months was deducted for other mitigating matters.

Mr Smith argued that the 10% deduction was too small. He also argued that his intoxication showed a lack of premeditation and so lowered his culpability.

The Supreme Court said the grounds did not meet the constitutional criteria. It said he had formulated no principle showing the trial judge erred on the plea deduction. It called the second ground misconceived, because self-induced intoxication is not otherwise a mitigating matter.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal