localnews.ie

William Mulrooney refused Supreme Court appeal over solicitors' file in legal costs dispute

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

He wanted the Court of Appeal to admit his former solicitors' file as new evidence in a review of a legal costs adjudication, and the court declined to take his appeal.

William Mulrooney has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his dispute with solicitors Dolph McGrath and Nicholas Shee, who practise as John Shee & Co. The court gave its decision on 10 December 2024. O'Malley J., Murray J. and Collins J. made the determination.

The dispute concerns a legal costs adjudication made on 18 November 2022. Mr Mulrooney had not obtained the solicitors' file before the adjudication, which went ahead on the documents the solicitors supplied. The High Court (O'Regan J.) approved the adjudication on 18 January 2024 and refused to order production of the file.

Mr Mulrooney appealed, and asked the Court of Appeal to admit the file as new evidence. Costello J. refused on 31 May 2024. She said he had not sought the file from the High Court while the adjudication was pending, and that the solicitors were entitled to assert privilege over it.

He argued that the refusal denied him fair procedures and made his statutory review pointless. The solicitors said the principles were well settled.

The Supreme Court found no matter of general public importance and no basis in the interests of justice. It said the law is settled and no new issues arise. It added that it is relatively rare for the constitutional threshold to be met in an interlocutory appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal