The Supreme Court has granted the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána leave to appeal in the case of Garda Raymond Hegarty, in a determination dated 9 February 2024. The Commissioner's application was late, and the court extended time.
Garda Hegarty is a serving member of the force. It was alleged that at Lismore Garda Station on 15 March 2017 he engaged in a sexual act with a witness while taking a statement from her. He was charged under the Garda Síochána Discipline Regulations with bringing discredit on the force and with failing to record the statement.
A Board of Inquiry determined that the incident and the breach of duty had occurred. It recommended that he resign as an alternative to dismissal, and a reduction in pay on the second issue. An Appeal Board later found the penalty on the first issue too severe.
The Commissioner then relied on section 14 of the Garda Síochána Act 2005, which allows him to dismiss a garda in certain circumstances. He suspended Garda Hegarty by notice dated 28 January 2020. Leave for judicial review was granted on 30 March 2020.
Ferriter J. ruled the Commissioner's decision unlawful in the High Court on 30 March 2022, and the Court of Appeal ruled in a similar way on 7 November 2023. The Commissioner argues that the section 14 power stands alone. Garda Hegarty says the decisions are correct and that the Discipline Regulations are the proper mechanism.
Charleton J, Woulfe J and Murray J said the limits of the Commissioner's powers are of importance, and noted that Garda discipline has led to public tribunals of enquiry. The court found the constitutional threshold of general public importance had been met.
Leave was granted on four issues. They include how the section 14 power works alongside the Discipline Regulations, and whether the Commissioner may depart from a Board of Inquiry's recommendation.