localnews.ie

Ciara Butler Duignan refused Supreme Court appeal over costs in Domiciliary Care Allowance case

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

Her judicial review became moot after the Social Welfare Appeals Office allowed her appeal, and the High Court made no order as to costs.

Ciara Butler Duignan has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over costs in her judicial review proceedings against the Chief Appeals Officer, Social Welfare Appeals Office, and the Minister for Social Protection. Dunne J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J. decided on 14 November 2024.

The refusal leaves in place the High Court's decision that there should be no order as to costs. That means she did not recover her costs of the proceedings.

Ms Butler Duignan applied for Domiciliary Care Allowance in October 2017 and was refused in January 2018. She appealed after a review decision of 23 October 2019 and sought judicial review in July 2022 to compel a decision. The appeal was allowed on 16 August 2022, which made the proceedings moot.

The High Court (Simons J.) found that the decision was not prompted or expedited by the proceedings. The Court of Appeal dismissed her appeal on 15 July 2024. She had conceded there was no causal link between the proceedings and the decision.

The Supreme Court said no matter of general public importance arises, because both courts applied well-established principles on costs in moot proceedings. It also said an appeal was not necessary in the interests of justice, as she had a full hearing in the High Court and a full appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal