Harry McHugh has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court against the High Court's decision to strike out his case against the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Ireland and the Attorney General. O'Donnell C.J., Charleton J. and Woulfe J. decided the application on 11 November 2024.
The refusal means the strike-out stands. Mr McHugh owns lands at Cashelgolan, Portnoo, Co. Donegal, which were part of a candidate special area of conservation. He was refused approval to plant 28.73 hectares of his land with forestry, and in September 2008 he sued for declarations and damages.
The High Court (Nolan J.) struck out the case on 11 April 2024 as bound to fail. The judge found that Mr McHugh did not own the lands when they were designated and so had no standing to challenge it. He also held that the claim was out of time.
Mr McHugh argued that his appeal raised matters of general public importance, including the compulsory acquisition of private property and the transposition of an EU directive.
The Supreme Court said the High Court had applied well-established principles on standing and time limits, which are case-specific. The points Mr McHugh raised related to the substance of his claim and did not arise from the High Court's decision. It found no interests of justice basis for an appeal.