The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by the Commission for Regulation of Utilities (CRU) in a case brought by GR Wind Farms 1 Limited and 19 other wind farm companies. It granted the CRU leave on 4 November 2024, allowing a direct appeal from the High Court. Eirgrid plc is a notice party.
The dispute began with a CRU decision of 22 March 2022 on dispatch, redispatch and compensation under Regulation (EU) 2019/43. The wind farm companies challenged it by judicial review. They argued that the CRU had failed to apply Article 13(7) of the regulation, which covers compensation when non-market based redispatching is needed.
The decision postponed compensation until the tariff year 2024/2025, although the regulation took effect on 1 January 2020. It also limited compensation to generators taking part in the ex ante market and provided for payments to intermediaries.
The High Court (Sanfey J.) then held that the CRU had acted outside its powers on each of those points. The CRU applied for leave to appeal after the High Court order of 10 July 2024. The wind farm companies did not oppose leave.
The Supreme Court, made up of Dunne J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J., found that the exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal were established. It said neither the meaning of Article 13(7) nor whether it has direct effect is straightforward, and that the outcome matters for the electricity market on the island of Ireland.
All parties accepted that questions on the interpretation of Article 13(7) should be referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union. The court will hold a case management hearing in very early course to expedite the appeal and clarify the grounds.