The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by An Bord Pleanála in a case taken by Peter Thomson and Doreen Thomson over a telecommunications mast in Kells, County Kilkenny. The court granted the board leave to appeal on 25 October 2024. Eircom Limited is a notice party.
The board decided on 17 June 2021 to grant Eircom permission to erect the mast in the village, close to the Thomsons' home. The couple later became concerned about the impartiality of Paul Hyde, former deputy chairperson of the board, who was one of two board members who decided to grant the permission.
They did not issue proceedings until 28 November 2022, well outside the eight-week limit for challenging a planning decision. The High Court (Humphreys J.) refused to extend time on 24 July 2023. It found that they had enough information to sue by mid-June 2022 and that there was no good and sufficient reason for the delay.
The Court of Appeal allowed the couple's appeal by a majority, with Allen J. dissenting. O'Moore J. found that the public interest in the systemic issues they raised about the board's operation was a good and sufficient reason to extend time.
The board argued that the ruling raises a novel point of general public importance and that the interests of justice require clarity. The Thomsons opposed leave, saying the decision was specific to its facts.
The Supreme Court said the appeal raises matters of general public importance on the test for extending time under section 50(8) of the Planning and Development Act 2000. It pointed to the weight given to the public interest and to the strength of the case, and to conflicting approaches in the High Court and the Court of Appeal. The grounds may be refined in case management. Charleton J., O'Malley J. and Woulfe J. decided the application.