Denis Jude Haughton has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his case against the Workplace Relations Commission and the Labour Court. The decision was delivered on 25 October 2024 by Charleton, O'Malley and Woulfe JJ.
Mr Haughton wanted an order of certiorari to compel the WRC to review its decision of 3 January 2023. He also sought an extension of time and an order certifying that work had been done since 2016, to release an advance of wages of around €100,000.
His complaint to the WRC was that he had not received a written statement of his terms of employment under the Terms of Employment Information Acts 1994. He claimed that correspondence with government bodies entitled him to cover as a deemed employee.
The High Court refused him leave to seek judicial review on 6 November 2023, finding no arguable grounds and that he was significantly out of time. The Court of Appeal refused leave on 18 April 2024. It held that, as he accepted he was never an employee of the Department of Justice, the Labour Court had no jurisdiction under the 1994 Act to hear his appeal.
The Supreme Court held that he had not established arguable grounds for judicial review or the necessary legal threshold. It found no argument for lowering the test below arguability and no apparent error requiring review.