localnews.ie

State Transport Leasing Company refused Supreme Court appeal in GTLK Europe aircraft case

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Russian state-owned company wanted to challenge a ruling that it could not appeal a High Court order voiding pledge agreements over 37 aircraft.

Joint Stock Company "State Transport Leasing Company" (JSC) has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a case brought by the liquidators of GTLK Europe DAC. The court announced its decision on 17 October 2024. Charleton, Collins and Donnelly JJ made the determination.

The liquidators, Julian Moroney and Damien Murran, asked the High Court to declare void pledge agreements under which JSC claimed ownership of 37 aircraft. The court heard that JSC did not appear in the High Court. The High Court declared the pledge agreement void, and the Court of Appeal later dismissed JSC's appeal.

The Court of Appeal found that JSC made a deliberate tactical decision not to take part, choosing instead to pursue proceedings in the Russian courts. It held that pursuing an appeal in those circumstances was an abuse of process.

JSC argued that the ruling raised points of general public importance and that its failure to appear was due to difficulties finding representation. It also said it paid €324 million to GTLK under the pledge agreements.

The Supreme Court said JSC had not identified any matter of general public importance. It also found that JSC had not shown that an appeal was necessary in the interests of justice, given the clear findings of abuse of process.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal