The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by John Fox in a dispute with Promontoria (Oyster) Designated Activity Company over whether a registered lien secures loans made after 2009. It granted Mr Fox leave to appeal on 16 September 2024.
Murray J., Collins J. and Donnelly J. made the determination. The court said the issue is one of general public importance and should be settled definitively by the Supreme Court.
Mr Fox owns registered land in County Westmeath. Before March 2009 he had deposited the land certificate with Ulster Bank Ireland Limited as security for borrowings. A lien was registered in the bank's favour on 19 March 2009. Two further loans were advanced in 2010, and those loans and the lien were later assigned to Promontoria.
Mr Fox defaulted on the 2010 loans. Promontoria asked for a well-charging order, which would declare his land charged with the sums due. He argued that the lien did not secure money advanced after 31 December 2009, so those sums were unsecured.
The High Court refused the order in a judgment of 7 March 2022. The Court of Appeal allowed Promontoria's appeal and set that judgment aside. It held that money advanced after the lien was registered, and after 31 December 2009, can be secured by the registered lien.
Mr Fox then sought leave to appeal. The Supreme Court said the question had not been decided in an earlier case on section 73 of the Registration of Deeds and Title Act 2006, because that case concerned a lien registered after 31 December 2009. It also pointed to the different conclusions reached by the High Court and the Court of Appeal.
The appeal will be managed together with Promontoria (Oyster) DAC v Kean, in which leave is also being granted, so the two can be heard together.