localnews.ie

Raymond and Irene Clarke refused Supreme Court appeal over Cavan home possession order

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

Start Mortgages DAC had been granted an order for possession of the couple's Cavan home, which the High Court affirmed on appeal.

Raymond and Irene Clarke have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against a High Court decision upholding an order for possession of their Cavan home. The Supreme Court decided on 13 September 2024 not to grant leave. Murray J., Collins J. and Donnelly J. made the determination.

Start Mortgages DAC sued for possession of the property, which is the couple's primary residence. It had advanced a loan on a 40-year term in 2007, with monthly repayments of €1,353.28 subject to interest rate changes. The balance demanded in January 2018 was €245,126.62.

The Circuit Court granted the possession order after hearing the couple, who appeared in person. The High Court then refused their appeal and affirmed that order. The couple argued that the possession order was contrary to EU law on unfair terms in consumer contracts.

The Supreme Court said the constitutional criteria for an appeal were not met. It found that the points raised as matters of general public importance were entirely general and that no concrete point of law had been identified. It also said an appeal was not in the interests of justice, because the High Court had carefully considered all grounds, including those based on EU law.

The Supreme Court also declined to refer questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal