localnews.ie

Joseph Kearns refused Supreme Court appeal against Eric Evenson over Court of Appeal costs order

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had ordered Mr Kearns to pay the costs of one appeal after he failed to mention an alleged settlement.

The Supreme Court has refused Joseph Kearns leave to appeal a Court of Appeal costs ruling in his case against Eric Evenson. The determination was delivered on 12 September 2024 by Justices Murray, Collins and Donnelly. Both parties had asked for more time, and the court granted it.

The dispute is about investments Mr Kearns and the Callary Pension Fund made between July 2011 and March 2012. Mr Kearns wants Mr Evenson, who lives in the Isle of Man, to repay the money. His plenary summons is dated May 2014.

The High Court set aside service of the summons on Mr Evenson. It then refused to renew the summons. The Court of Appeal dismissed both of Mr Kearns's appeals.

On 21 March 2024, the Court of Appeal ruled on costs. It said Mr Kearns had claimed a compromise agreement in August 2021, covering costs. He had not told the courts about it before the appeals were decided. It ordered him to pay Mr Evenson's costs, limited to one appeal rather than two.

Mr Kearns argued that the court misapplied the law on costs and estoppel. The Supreme Court said he raised no novel point of wide application. It said the Court of Appeal was entitled to deal with costs as it did.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal