localnews.ie

Niall and Joyce Hade refused Supreme Court appeal over Bank of Ireland receiver sales

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The High Court had awarded €550,000 in exemplary damages against the receiver, but the Court of Appeal set the award aside.

The Supreme Court has refused Niall Hade and Joyce Hade leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in their dispute with Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank U.C. The determination was delivered on 29 August 2024 by Justices Dunne, O'Malley and Hogan. The High Court had awarded €550,000 in exemplary damages against the receiver, Michael McAteer.

The Hades had two loans, from 2006 and 2007, secured on a portfolio of twelve buy-to-let properties. They fell into arrears by August 2011. The Bank appointed a receiver, who took possession of all twelve properties and sold three in 2014 without a court order.

The Bank sued for €2,026,640.09 against both applicants and €1,412,210.09 against Mr Hade alone. Mr Hade sued the Bank and the receiver for negligence. The High Court ruled for the Bank on most grounds, but held the receiver acted unlawfully in selling without a possession order.

The Court of Appeal ruled on 7 December 2023 that a receiver does not need a possession order, and set the damages aside. It also upheld findings that the Hades were not consumers under the Consumer Credit Act 1995.

The Supreme Court found no issue of general public importance in any of their points. It said the receiver's powers were governed by standard clauses and well-established case law. It added that costs orders are rarely disturbed.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal