localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear Ballyboden Tidy Towns appeal over Stocking Avenue housing

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The group won leave to appeal directly from the High Court, which let Ardstone Homes defend a 241-dwelling permission that An Bord Pleanála had conceded.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Ballyboden Tidy Towns Group in its judicial review case against An Bord Pleanála. It granted leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a determination delivered on 10 July 2023.

Ardstone Homes Limited was granted permission to build housing developments at Stocking Avenue, Dublin 16. The permission for one element, White Pines East, covered 241 dwellings and was granted on 19 July 2021. The tidy towns group challenged it, and one ground said the Board had failed to assess whether there was adequate public transport capacity.

On 13 May 2022 the Board told the parties it would concede that ground. Ardstone then applied for liberty to defend the point. The High Court (Humphreys J) held that Ardstone was entitled to defend the proceedings despite the concession. The group applied to the Supreme Court in May 2023.

The group argued that the decision conflicts with an earlier High Court ruling in Protect East Meath v An Bord Pleanála. It said the issue is purely legal and that other cases raise the same point.

An Bord Pleanála and the Attorney General did not oppose leave. Ardstone opposed it, arguing that a notice party is entitled to defend a decision in which it has a material interest. It said further delay to the 241 units was not in the interests of justice. All parties asked for a priority hearing.

The Supreme Court called the issue novel but important. It asked when a party that benefited from a decision can keep defending it after the decision-maker has conceded it should be quashed, and what threshold applies. It said the issues could have implications for other judicial review cases. The grounds of appeal can be refined at case management. The panel was Dunne J, Baker J and Donnelly J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal