The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Unite the Union and three of its members against an injunction granted to H.A. O'Neil Limited. In a determination delivered on 21 June 2023, it granted leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The three individual applicants are Patrick James Goold, William Mangan and Damian Jones.
H.A. O'Neil sought an interlocutory injunction to stop the defendants watching, besetting or picketing its premises, and to stop them representing that a trade dispute existed with its employees. The order sought against the three individuals would have required each of them to attend their place of work in County Kildare. The company had been served with a dispute notice from the union, and a strike had gone ahead on a particular day.
The dispute was mainly about including travel time in basic pay. The Labour Court had refused the union's claim on that point in November 2022. The company argued that a ballot of the whole sector was required before industrial action, but the union had balloted only some of its members.
In an ex tempore judgment on 23 March 2023, the High Court (O'Regan J) found that the company had raised a fair issue to be tried. An order followed on 18 April 2023. The applicants applied to the Supreme Court on 5 May 2023, in time. The company opposed leave. It argued that the case raised no matter of general public importance, affected a small minority of workers and was better suited to the Court of Appeal first.
The Supreme Court disagreed. It held that a point of general public importance arises about how section 19(2) of the Industrial Relations Act 1990 interacts with the court's general power to grant injunctions. It also held that a point arises about the kind of ballot a union must hold. It said these issues are likely to affect other trade disputes.
The court was satisfied that the point is wholly one of law, and that the appeal was unlikely to look different after a Court of Appeal hearing. It rejected the argument about the small number of members balloted. The panel was Charleton J, Baker J and Woulfe J.