William Fitzgerald has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his challenge to a drunk driving conviction. The determination was delivered on 16 June 2023.
Mr Fitzgerald was convicted at Fermoy District Court on 22 February 2019. He was fined €500 and disqualified from holding a driving licence for twelve months. He sought judicial review of the District Court judge's decisions, arguing that he had been denied disclosure of evidence such as CCTV footage, GPS data and radio system data from the Garda patrol car.
The High Court refused him leave to bring the judicial review. The Court of Appeal then dismissed his appeal on all points, holding that the disclosure refusals were made because the judge did not consider the material relevant.
In the Supreme Court he argued that the State had failed to comply with an EU directive on the right to information in criminal proceedings. He also argued that each Court of Appeal judge must give judgment publicly.
The Supreme Court said the directive largely mirrors Irish law on disclosure. It said his argument about training under the directive was raised for the first time and could not be considered. It found him mistaken that each judge must pronounce judgment, and added that two of the judges had in fact stated that they agreed with the lead judgment.
The panel was Charleton J, Baker J and Woulfe J.