Brian McDonagh, Kenneth McDonagh and Maurice McDonagh have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in their case with Ulster Bank Ireland DAC. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 16 June 2023.
The three men had asked the Court of Appeal to set aside its own judgment of 6 April 2022 on grounds of objective bias. Their argument was that Collins J, a member of that court, had acted while in practice for the bank. They also said he had represented the receivers, Paul McCann and Patrick Dillon, in other proceedings.
The Court of Appeal dismissed that application on 28 July 2022. It relied on an earlier Irish case, Bula v Tara Mines (No. 6), which held that a judge who acted for a party in a separate and unconnected matter is not disqualified from hearing a later case.
The Supreme Court said there was no suggestion of any factual connection between those earlier proceedings and this one. It found that the Court of Appeal had applied well-established case law.
The men's attempt to distinguish the earlier case gave no plausible basis for departing from it. The court was not satisfied that the case raised a matter of general public importance or that the interests of justice required an appeal. The panel was O'Donnell C.J. with Dunne and O'Malley JJ.