localnews.ie

Martin Tucker refused Supreme Court appeal over Havbell property fraud claim

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court declined a direct appeal from the High Court, which had refused him leave to challenge possession orders on a fraud claim.

Martin Tucker has been refused leave to bring a direct appeal from the High Court to the Supreme Court in his case against Havbell Designated Activity Company. The determination was delivered on 14 June 2023.

The dispute began with a mortgage that Mr Tucker and his former partner took out with Permanent TSB on a property at Clontarf, Dublin 3. In June 2015 Permanent TSB sold the loan to Havbell. After the account fell into arrears, Havbell brought Circuit Court proceedings, and an order for possession was made in 2018.

Mr Tucker's later efforts to challenge that order failed. He issued fresh proceedings in 2020, and the High Court dismissed that action. Restrictions were placed on any further proceedings over the property without leave.

Mr Tucker then asked the President of the High Court for leave to bring a motion from the Circuit Court office to set aside the possession orders, on the basis that they were obtained by fraud. The President refused, holding that any such application would be frivolous and vexatious. That is the decision Mr Tucker wished to appeal.

The Supreme Court said he had not set out any matter of general public importance or any basis in the interests of justice. It said the High Court decision applied well-established principles on leave to bring proceedings where such a restriction is in place.

The panel was Charleton J, Baker J and Woulfe J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal