Sean Furlong has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his challenge to a prosecution for two counts of assault causing harm, the court ruled on 30 January 2023.
Both alleged assaults took place on 22 May 2017 in Bluebell, Dublin, five days after Mr Furlong turned 17. He turned 18 on 17 May 2018, before he was charged, which meant the Children Act 2001 no longer applied to him. He brought a judicial review seeking to stop the trial on the ground of prosecutorial delay.
The High Court agreed that delay by the prosecution had caused him significant prejudice that outweighed the public interest in the trial. The Court of Appeal found that the delay was blameworthy. It then balanced the prejudice against the public interest, and allowed the Director of Public Prosecutions' appeal.
Mr Furlong asked the Supreme Court to hear the case. The DPP opposed leave. The panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Murray said the law was settled by the decision in Donoghue v DPP, and the balancing exercise depends on the facts of each case. It found no issue of general public importance and no need for a further appeal in the interests of justice.
Leave to appeal was refused.