Martin Tucker has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his long-running dispute with Havbell Designated Activity Company. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 14 June 2023.
Mr Tucker wanted to appeal a Court of Appeal decision of 8 February 2023. That court had dismissed his appeal against a High Court order throwing out his action. The High Court found that his claim to possession of the property was res judicata, meaning it had already been decided. It also found that his claim about a settlement agreement was bound to fail.
The case arose from a mortgage on a property at Clontarf, Dublin 3. Havbell took over the loan in June 2015 and later sought possession. An order for possession was made in the Circuit Court in 2018.
Mr Tucker argued that the order had been obtained by fraud. He also raised data protection and credit institution points. The Supreme Court said he had not properly raised any matter of general public importance. He had not particularised the fraud claim in the lower courts, and the other two points were new.
The court also found that the interests of justice did not require a further appeal. It said he had already had a full hearing in the High Court and a full appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The panel was Charleton J, Baker J and Woulfe J.