The Supreme Court has granted Seán Lane leave to appeal to it from the Court of Appeal, in a determination delivered on 12 June 2023. Mr Lane was convicted of intentionally or recklessly causing serious harm to Eamon Sheehy and of producing a baseball bat in the course of a dispute or fight.
The attack happened on 14 January 2018 at Saint Stephen's Park, Castleisland, County Kerry. The determination records that Mr Sheehy was left permanently brain damaged and close to death. Mr Lane pleaded not guilty and was tried with a co-accused, Jason Cían Broderick, at Tralee Circuit Court. He was found guilty on both counts against him and was sentenced to nine years in prison. Mr Broderick was convicted of a separate offence of having a baseball bat with him in a public place.
The decision he wants to appeal is a Court of Appeal order made on 7 November 2022. He applied to the Supreme Court on 25 April 2023, and the determination notes that the application was out of time.
His complaint is that his co-accused helped the prosecution. He says he should have been given a separate trial. In garda interviews Mr Broderick had described Mr Lane attacking Mr Sheehy with a baseball bat, and those statements were read to the jury. Mr Lane also objects to the closing speech made for Mr Broderick. An application for separate trials was made on the fourth day of the trial and was supported by Mr Lane, but it was not granted. The Director of Public Prosecutions told the Supreme Court that no question of general importance arises and that settled law was applied.
The Supreme Court panel of Justices Charleton, Baker and Woulfe disagreed. They said issues of wide application arise about statements in which an accused excuses himself or blames a co-accused, and about when and how a judge should exercise the discretion to order separate trials.
The appeal will deal with six questions. They include what warning a trial judge should give a jury about such statements, when separate trials should be ordered, when an application for them should be made, and what limits apply to what counsel for a co-accused may say in a closing speech. The determination is a decision to hear the appeal only. It does not decide whether Mr Lane's conviction was safe.