localnews.ie

John Faulkner granted Supreme Court appeal over 12-year burglary sentence

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will consider how burglary sentences are set and how to sentence separate offences committed in one episode.

The Supreme Court on 12 June 2023 granted John Faulkner leave to appeal against his sentence for burglary, endangerment and dangerous driving. It extended the time for his application.

Mr Faulkner was the driver in a burglary at a house near Charleville, Co. Cork, on 19 October 2019. Two co-accused pleaded guilty. He pleaded not guilty, and a jury at Cork Circuit Court convicted him on three counts.

On 22 April 2021 the judge sentenced him to 12 years for burglary, two years for endangerment and six months for dangerous driving. He was disqualified from driving for 20 years. The Court of Appeal dealt with the case on 15 December 2022.

Mr Faulkner said his headline sentence was markedly different from those of his co-accused, who received nine years. The Supreme Court noted that they took no part in the endangerment or the dangerous driving.

The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave, saying the law on burglary sentencing, totality and disparity is well settled.

The Supreme Court panel of Mr Justice Charleton, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Woulfe said the issues are important for sentencing courts. It set out four matters for the appeal, which may be refined at case management.

They are whether the criteria in The People (DPP) v Casey are definitive guidelines for burglary, and how a headline sentence is set when a co-accused has already pleaded guilty. They also include whether a separate sentence must be fixed for each offence, or whether offences in one event can be sentenced as a whole, and whether the sentences should be adjusted.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal