The Supreme Court on 12 June 2023 refused John O'Connor leave to appeal in his litigation against the Legal Aid Board, the Minister for Justice and Equality, Ireland and the Attorney General.
Mr O'Connor brought three sets of proceedings in 2018 and 2019. They arose from his dealings with the Legal Aid Board over legal aid certificates for professional negligence cases. He claimed damages on several grounds, including breach of contract, breach of constitutional rights and negligence. He also alleged that letters from a Board solicitor were defamatory.
The State defendants asked for the claims against them to be dismissed. The High Court agreed. It held that sections 3 and 7(3) of the Legal Aid Board Act 1995 prevent the Minister from controlling the Board in individual cases, so the State could not be held liable for the Board's acts. The Court of Appeal upheld that decision and rejected his arguments on judgment in default of defence.
Mr O'Connor put forward 12 grounds of appeal. They included bias and a refused stay on costs. The respondents said the courts had made no errors.
The Supreme Court panel of Chief Justice O'Donnell, Mr Justice Murray and Mr Justice Collins found no issue of public importance and no need for an appeal in the interests of justice. It said the lower courts applied well-established principles.
The court also noted that the dismissal did not affect his claims against the Legal Aid Board itself.