The Supreme Court on 25 May 2023 refused Lawrence Shields leave to appeal directly from the High Court in his judicial review against the Central Bank of Ireland.
Mr Shields asked the Central Bank to replace damaged banknotes. The bank decided in November 2019 to replace the first batch, which was worth €4,950. It then applied to have his judicial review struck out as moot. On 15 October 2020 Mr Justice Barr agreed, and the Court of Appeal later dismissed his appeal.
Mr Shields then applied to the Supreme Court for leave to appeal the High Court decision itself. He relied on Article 34.5.4° of the Constitution, which allows a direct appeal from the High Court. His application was out of time. The court did not decide it on that point alone.
The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Mr Justice Woulfe and Mr Justice Hogan noted that this appeared to be the first time a litigant had sought a direct appeal from a High Court decision already decided on its merits by the Court of Appeal. It said the Court of Appeal's decision replaces the High Court's. Article 34.4.3° makes the Court of Appeal's decision final and conclusive, except where leave to appeal to the Supreme Court is available.
The court was not satisfied that it had jurisdiction under Article 34.5.4° and refused leave.