localnews.ie

Lawrence Shields refused Supreme Court appeal in Central Bank damaged banknotes case

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had held his judicial review moot after the Central Bank exchanged the €4,950 in damaged notes he had submitted.

The Supreme Court on 25 May 2023 refused Lawrence Shields leave to appeal in his judicial review against the Central Bank of Ireland over damaged banknotes.

Mr Shields makes fibreglass objects of art. He said some €10,000 in notes was accidentally damaged in a fire at his workshop. In early 2019 he sent the Central Bank a first batch of damaged notes worth €4,950 and asked for replacements.

The bank first said the notes had been intentionally damaged. It withheld them. Mr Shields began judicial review proceedings. On 6 November 2019 the bank decided to replace the notes after all.

The bank then asked the High Court to strike the case out as moot, meaning there was nothing left to decide. Mr Justice Barr agreed. The Court of Appeal dismissed Mr Shields's appeal on 26 October 2022.

Mr Shields argued that the Irish courts had no jurisdiction because the matter concerned a decision of the European Central Bank.

The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Mr Justice Woulfe and Mr Justice Hogan said the case was moot whatever the answer on jurisdiction. The money had been exchanged. The lower courts applied well-established principles, and the court found no issue of general public importance. Leave was refused.

This is one of three applications Mr Shields made to the Supreme Court.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal