localnews.ie

Anthony and Paula Galibert refused Supreme Court appeal in Start Mortgages possession case

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Waterford couple wanted a direct appeal from a High Court order giving the lender possession of their family home.

The Supreme Court on 25 May 2023 refused Anthony and Paula Galibert leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a possession case brought by Start Mortgages DAC.

The couple live in a family home in Co. Waterford. In March 2008 Start Mortgages agreed to lend them €211,650, secured by a first charge on the property. They fell into arrears before the end of 2008 and stopped paying altogether in 2015. The lender claimed €298,328.91 as the outstanding balance.

The Circuit Court sent the case to a plenary hearing. Start Mortgages appealed, and Ms Justice Phelan reversed that decision in the High Court. She found the lender entitled to possession and found no credible defence. She ordered the couple to give up the home, with a six-month stay.

The Galiberts argued that the lender had no banking licence for part of 2008 and was not the holder of the mortgage note. They also said the judge had failed to hear their oral argument. Start Mortgages opposed leave.

The Supreme Court panel of Chief Justice O'Donnell, Ms Justice O'Malley and Mr Justice Hogan called the defences well-worn and technical. It said there is no tort of negligent lending. It found no matter of general public importance and nothing in the interests of justice to justify a direct appeal. Leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal