The Supreme Court on 25 May 2023 refused Rezaul Karim leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision that he oppressed a company director under section 212 of the Companies Act 2014.
The dispute concerns SEDA (Skills & Enterprise Academy) Limited, which operates an English language college on Capel Street, Dublin. Mr Karim acted as a consultant to the company. His wife, Mahbuba Sultana, was a founding shareholder. Tiago Mascarenhas, a director and secretary, brought the proceedings in 2017 after a long dispute over the use of company money and its governance.
On 23 May 2019 Mr Justice Jordan found that Mr Karim's conduct was an attempt to dominate Mr Mascarenhas. He called it burdensome, harsh and wrongful, and held that it amounted to oppression. He directed Ms Sultana to sell her shareholding to Mr Mascarenhas if he was willing to buy at a price fixed by the court.
The Court of Appeal affirmed that decision. Ms Justice Costello held that Mr Karim could not avoid the finding by saying he was neither a director nor a shareholder, because oppressive conduct is judged by objective standards.
Mr Karim applied alone to the Supreme Court. Ms Sultana did not. Mr Mascarenhas opposed leave.
The Supreme Court panel of Chief Justice O'Donnell, Ms Justice O'Malley and Mr Justice Hogan said his points rested on settled company law applied to the facts. It found no matter of general public importance and no need for leave in the interests of justice.