The Supreme Court on 19 May 2023 refused Antonio Casimiro Lopes leave to appeal in his case against Ireland and the Attorney General.
Mr Lopes began the current proceedings in 2020. They stem from his long-running dissatisfaction with the damages he received in a professional negligence action. The Supreme Court had dismissed an earlier case of his in March 2014.
On 23 June 2022 the High Court dismissed the new proceedings. It found the matters were either already decided or had no evidential basis.
Mr Lopes appealed to the Court of Appeal. He was given extensions to file written submissions but did not do so, saying he was unwell. On 24 February 2023 the Court of Appeal ordered that his appeal would be struck out if he did not file by 27 February. He did not, and the order took effect.
The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice O'Malley, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Hogan said case management decisions rarely raise a point of general public importance. It said a general claim of ill health, with no medical report, was not enough to show he was treated unfairly. It said no basis had been put forward for his allegations that judges acted improperly.
Leave to appeal was refused.