localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear RSA Insurance and Urban and Rural Recycling appeal against Zurich

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal will decide which insurer must cover a worker's claim for injuries from a falling wheelie bin, and how far compulsory motor insurance reaches.

The Supreme Court on 19 May 2023 granted Urban and Rural Recycling Limited and RSA Insurance Ireland DAC leave to appeal against Zurich Insurance plc. The case is a dispute between two insurers over which of them must answer a worker's injury claim.

On 19 December 2013 an employee of Urban and Rural Recycling, Joseph Moore, suffered injuries the court described as devastating and life-changing. A plastic wheelie bin holding glass fell on his head as he used a mechanical lift on a recycling truck. He sued his employer for negligence. The employer had two policies. One was an employer's liability policy with RSA, and the other was a motor policy with Zurich.

The parties agreed a special case for the High Court. It had to decide whether the employer's liability was one that the Road Traffic Acts required to be insured. On 3 September 2021 Ms Justice Reynolds held that it was, so the employer was entitled to indemnity under the Zurich policy.

The Court of Appeal reversed that decision. Mr Justice Allen held that the liability required to be insured was the employer's vicarious liability for use of the vehicle by Mr Moore. As Mr Moore could not be liable to himself, he found there was no such liability.

RSA applied for leave. It said the case raises far-reaching questions about compulsory insurance, and about the meaning of "driver" in a 2009 EU directive. Zurich said it was a contractual dispute between two private insurers.

The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice O'Malley, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Hogan found significant issues about the extent of the mandatory insurance obligation. It said these have implications for virtually all road users, and may need EU law interpretation. Leave was granted, and the questions may be refined at case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal