The Supreme Court on 15 May 2023 refused David Kavanagh leave to appeal directly from the High Court. He had been refused leave to bring a judicial review against the Coalition Government of Ireland and the President of Ireland.
Mr Kavanagh wanted to challenge the constitutionality of the 2020 agreement between the parties in government. Under it, the leaders of the two larger parties are nominated in turn as Taoiseach and serve as Tánaiste while the other holds the office. He argued that the arrangement invalidated the other government positions. He also argued that all legislation passed since the relevant date was unconstitutional.
He sought a complete cessation of the functions of the Government and the President, and orders nullifying all laws enacted between 27 June 2020 and 17 December 2022. Mr Justice Meenan refused leave to seek judicial review on 27 March 2023, finding that no breach of the Constitution had been identified.
The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice O'Malley, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Collins noted that Mr Kavanagh had not explained why he applied directly to the Supreme Court rather than appealing to the Court of Appeal. It said his arguments did not engage with the constitutional structure of the State.
The court said the President must appoint as Taoiseach the person nominated by Dáil Éireann. It said the Taoiseach alone appoints the Tánaiste, and that a political agreement between members is of political significance only. Leave to appeal was refused.