The Supreme Court on 15 May 2023 refused Maciej Masznicz leave to appeal against his drug and firearms convictions, which the Court of Appeal had upheld on 18 October 2022.
Mr Masznicz was tried by a jury at Tralee Circuit Criminal Court in February 2019. He pleaded guilty to one count of simple possession of cannabis, and not guilty to the rest. He was convicted on all counts, including possession of drugs worth €13,000 or more for sale or supply, and possession of an unauthorised stun gun. He was sentenced on 16 July 2019.
The drugs were found in a locked shed in a gated farmyard that he used regularly. He first raised problems with the judge's charge to the jury in his appeal. He said that possession and circumstantial evidence had not been explained properly. The Court of Appeal found that the charge had some defects but was fair overall. It concluded that no fundamental injustice had occurred.
Mr Masznicz said the Court of Appeal misapplied the test in DPP v Cronin (No. 2) for raising a new point on appeal. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave.
The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Woulfe found that the Court of Appeal had applied the correct principles and dealt with the new points. It identified no point of general public importance, and said the interests of justice did not warrant leave.