The Supreme Court on 15 May 2023 granted Concerned Residents of Treascon and Clondoolusk leave to appeal against a High Court decision on a solar farm in Co. Offaly.
An Bord Pleanála granted planning permission on 4 October 2021 to Elgin Energy Services Limited, the notice party. It allows a solar powered electricity generating station on a site of about 90 hectares in the townlands of Treascon and Clondoolusk, Portarlington. The board was ruling on an appeal from a decision by Offaly County Council.
The residents brought a judicial review on domestic law and EU law grounds. Mr Justice Humphreys rejected all of them on 16 December 2022. He refused leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal and refused to refer a question to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Part of the case concerns the Environmental Impact Assessment Directive. The development would remove 770 metres of hedgerow and set back another 140 metres. That requires screening under the 2011 agriculture regulations, which may lead to an environmental impact assessment.
The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice O'Malley, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Collins said the proper transposition of the Directive is a matter of general public importance. It pointed to questions about the scope of any assessment, and whether the whole development must be assessed or only the part restructuring rural land. It also found exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal, because the residents had been refused leave to go to the Court of Appeal.
The respondents and Elgin opposed leave. Elgin asked for a priority hearing, but the court said no formal order was needed. A case management conference will be held early on.