The Supreme Court on 8 May 2023 refused Liam O'Brien leave to appeal against his rape conviction. His conviction stands.
Mr O'Brien was convicted of rape on 23 April 2021. A jury convicted him and acquitted a co-accused at the same trial.
He appealed to the Court of Appeal, which dismissed the appeal. He had argued that a jury could not infer a lack of consent unless the complainant gave direct evidence that she did not consent. He had also argued that the verdict was perverse, because the co-accused was acquitted. The Court of Appeal held that the jury was entitled to infer a lack of consent from the complainant's evidence.
Mr O'Brien then applied to the Supreme Court. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave.
The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Mr Justice Woulfe and Mr Justice Murray said the evidence needed to show a lack of consent depends on the case. Where there is enough evidence to go to a jury, it said, the question is a matter for the jury. It added that the Court of Appeal had applied well-established case law in rejecting the claim that the verdict was perverse.
The court was not satisfied that either issue met the constitutional threshold. Leave to appeal was refused.