The Supreme Court on 5 May 2023 refused Deirdre Brennan leave to appeal in her case against the Minister for Employment Affairs and Social Protection.
Ms Brennan applied for the One Parent Family Payment. She is separated from her partner but still lives in a house they own jointly. He pays the mortgage in full, at €1,161.36 a month.
The Department counted those payments when it assessed her means. The rules count housing costs paid by a liable relative above €4,952 a year. Ms Brennan said only half of the repayments should count, because her ex-partner co-owns the house. She pointed to an earlier decision of the Chief Appeals Officer that took that approach.
The High Court and the Court of Appeal both held that the full amount was correctly used. The Court of Appeal's judgment was delivered in January 2023.
The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Mr Justice Charleton and Ms Justice Baker said her case was about applying the regulation to her own facts. It was not about the meaning of "net cash value". The court said she had not met the constitutional threshold for leave.
The Minister opposed the application.