localnews.ie

Sergejs Radionovs surrender case goes to Supreme Court on Minister for Justice appeal

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Minister is challenging a High Court refusal to surrender Mr Radionovs to Latvia to serve a sentence of one year and one day.

The Supreme Court on 19 January 2023 granted the Minister for Justice leave to appeal directly from the High Court in the case of Sergejs Radionovs.

Latvia issued a European Arrest Warrant seeking Mr Radionovs's surrender to serve a sentence of one year and one day. A Latvian court had imposed it in his absence. It converted a period of unserved police supervision into a custodial sentence.

The warrant was endorsed by the High Court on 21 December 2021, and he was arrested that day. Mr Radionovs resisted surrender under section 45 of the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003. That section bars surrender where a person did not appear in person at the proceeding that led to the sentence, unless certain conditions are met.

Ms Justice Biggs refused surrender in an ex tempore judgment on 27 July 2022, and gave written reasons on 19 October 2022. She held that the conversion of the sentence was not a separate trial under the CJEU's Ardic reasoning. She still found a breach of section 45. Mr Radionovs knew he faced a fine for failing to attend a police station. He did not know a further court hearing could turn his supervision into imprisonment. She refused a certificate of leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.

The Minister said the High Court had not fully applied Ardic. The Minister also said the High Court had imported a knowledge requirement, with wider consequences for suspended sentences. Mr Radionovs opposed leave.

The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Murray found a point of general public importance. It concerns how Ardic interacts with section 45 where a suspended sentence is activated. It also found that the interests of justice required an appeal, since the point would not now reach the Court of Appeal.

Leave was granted. The court said case management may have to consider a related reference to the CJEU.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal