Adrian Caulfield has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his personal injuries case against Tony Gillen, from whom he rented an apartment in Dublin. The decision was delivered on 20 April 2023.
The proceedings centre on an incident at the apartment on 23 September 2008. Mr Caulfield applied to the Private Residential Tenancies Board on 27 February 2009. A final determination order found that his tenancy had been unlawfully terminated.
He applied to the Personal Injuries Assessment Board on 19 March 2010. His personal injuries summons is dated 27 June 2011. On 25 June 2021 the Circuit Court dismissed the proceedings for want of prosecution, with costs to Mr Gillen.
Mr Caulfield appealed to the High Court. Heslin J held that the delay had caused at least moderate prejudice to Mr Gillen and dismissed the appeal.
The panel of Dunne J., O'Malley J. and Murray J. refused leave. It found no exceptional circumstances to justify a direct appeal, noting that the cause of action arose over a decade ago. It said Mr Caulfield's arguments were specific to his own case and raised no matter of general public importance. It added that Heslin J's judgment proceeded on well-established legal principle.