localnews.ie

Margaret Hassett, Timothy Cremin and City Learning granted Supreme Court appeal in Mary Munnelly case

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear a direct appeal from the High Court on how a rule against repeat litigation applies to people who were not parties to the first case.

Margaret Hassett, Timothy Cremin and City Learning Limited have been granted leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in a case brought by Mary Munnelly. The decision was delivered on 20 April 2023.

Ms Munnelly left her employment with City Learning in 2015. She claimed an incident amounted to bullying and harassment by Ms Hassett and gave rise to constructive dismissal. The parties dispute whether she was an employee or an independent contractor. In 2016 she sued the company alone, and Groarke P. dismissed that claim on 28 November 2018 with no order as to costs. She did not appeal.

On 15 March 2019 Ms Munnelly began new proceedings against the company, Ms Hassett and Mr Cremin, the company's Chief Executive. The defendants asked the Circuit Court to dismiss them as bound to fail. They relied on the rule in Henderson v Henderson, which requires parties to bring forward the whole case in the first proceedings. They also said she had not applied to the Personal Injuries Assessment Board as section 12 of the 2003 Act requires.

The Circuit Court struck out the proceedings. Barr J reversed that decision in the High Court. He held that the earlier judge had made no finding on bullying and harassment, so the Henderson rule did not apply. He also held that the case fell within a provision of the 2003 Act that excludes actions claiming relief for another cause of action.

The defendants sought a direct appeal, saying no appeal lies to the Court of Appeal from the High Court on a Circuit Court appeal. The panel of O'Donnell C.J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J. granted leave. It said the Personal Injuries Assessment Board point did not raise a point of general public importance. It said the Henderson point raises questions, including whether the principle can be invoked by parties who were not parties to the first decision.

Ms Munnelly represented herself in the High Court. The court told her about a scheme under which solicitors and counsel represent parties in Supreme Court appeals for free. If she tells the Registrar within a fortnight that she wants to use it, a solicitor and counsel will be assigned.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal