Kevin Meehan has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over a reduced personal injuries award. The decision was delivered on 6 April 2023.
Mr Meehan was injured in July 2011 when a lift he was in went into free fall. He suffered fractures to three vertebrae, his right knee and his right foot. He also had other physical, dental and psychological injuries.
Liability was not in issue. In the High Court, Hanna J awarded him a total of €508,649. That included €133,649 in special damages.
The Court of Appeal found the assessment of damages was disproportionate. It reduced general damages to €200,000. It noted that Mr Meehan had made a remarkable recovery and led a normal and rewarding life, with some limitations.
Mr Meehan argued that the Court of Appeal had misapplied the principles of proportionality. He said the decision penalised him for mitigating his loss. The respondents said the issues were well settled by case law.
The panel of Dunne J., O'Malley J. and Murray J. refused leave. It said the Court of Appeal had regard to existing case law and applied it carefully. It found that Mr Meehan had not met the constitutional threshold for a further appeal.