localnews.ie

Angela Kerins granted Supreme Court appeal over Public Accounts Committee discovery

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The former Rehab Group chief executive wants documents held by the Dáil Clerk to support her damages claim over her 2014 appearance before the committee.

The Supreme Court on 19 January 2023 granted Angela Kerins, the former chief executive of the Rehab Group, leave to appeal directly from the High Court in her case against Dáil Éireann, Ireland and the Attorney General.

Her claim arises from her appearance before the Public Accounts Committee on 11 February 2014. The court noted that she was before the committee for about seven hours with one short break. She was questioned on matters well beyond those she had been told about in advance.

The case has been heard in two modules. In the first, the Supreme Court found that the committee had acted unlawfully in how it questioned her. The second module concerns what damages she can be awarded. As part of it, she sought discovery of documents held by the Clerk of Dáil Éireann.

In July 2022 Mr Justice Owens refused to order discovery. He held that Article 15.13 of the Constitution barred him, because her claim called for judgment on speeches and debate by members of the Dáil. He awarded her one third of her costs for the application.

The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Murray said it would not normally give leave on an interlocutory matter such as discovery. This case went beyond that, it said, because it raises an important question about what discovery can be made of the committee's documents when the court has already found the committee acted unlawfully. The question turns on the interpretation of Articles 15.10, 15.12 and 15.3 of the Constitution.

The court said an appeal to the Court of Appeal would inevitably be followed by an application to the Supreme Court, so it granted a direct appeal. The respondents opposed leave. They were also given leave to cross-appeal on the costs order.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal