Joseph Reynolds has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over costs in a High Court application under Article 40.4 of the Constitution. The decision was delivered on 29 March 2023.
Mr Reynolds was arrested during a protest in Dublin in February 2021 and charged with a public order offence. The District Judge granted bail on conditions that included a cash lodgement of €100, reduced to €50 after the court was told Mr Reynolds was homeless and had €7 on him.
Mr Reynolds applied to the High Court under Article 40.4 on the following Monday, but the money was lodged and he was released. Meenan J made no order as to costs, and the Court of Appeal also made no order after finding the condition was not unreasonable, disproportionate or irrational.
The panel of O'Donnell C.J., O'Malley J. and Hogan J. refused leave. It said the application had rested on two factual propositions: that the figure was unattainable and that cash could not be lodged over the weekend. Both proved wrong. It found no point of general public importance concerning excessive bail, and noted that the Custody Legal Issues Scheme is available for legal fees in such applications.