localnews.ie

Killegland Estates granted Supreme Court appeal over Meath County Council rezoning

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The company's lands in County Meath had been zoned for housing since 2001 before the 2021-2027 development plan changed them to community infrastructure.

On 28 March 2023 the Supreme Court granted Killegland Estates Limited leave to appeal directly to it in a planning case against Meath County Council.

The company owns lands in County Meath that had been zoned for housing since 2001. The Meath County Development Plan 2021-2027 downzoned them to community infrastructure. The company wants the plan quashed in so far as it affects those lands.

The draft plan would have kept the housing zoning. The elected members of the council then resolved to rezone the land as community infrastructure. They planned to use it as an access site and entrance to a linear park. The Chief Executive recommended against this, citing the principle of sequential development, but the members rejected that advice.

Part of the debate concerned housing on lands owned by Cornelius Giltinane and Patricia Giltinane, who are notice parties. The members resolved to rezone that land from rural area to new residential. The Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage later issued a statutory directive that reversed that rezoning. It did not change the decision on Killegland's land.

The High Court refused the reliefs sought, and Humphreys J also refused a certificate of leave to appeal. He held that the reasons for the decision could be found in the minutes and transcripts of the meetings. He said they did not have to be set out in the resolution itself. He also held that a challenge to a decision within a development plan must challenge the plan's core strategy.

Killegland argued that the decision was unreasoned and that the council had to address its submissions. The Supreme Court panel of O'Donnell J., O'Malley J. and Hogan J. found points of general public importance. These cover the nature of a development plan and how part of a plan can be challenged. They also cover the duty to give reasons for rezoning and to address submissions. The parties asked for a priority hearing. The court said the matter can be heard in early course if directions in case management are followed. It will be listed with the McGarrell Reilly Homes appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal