McGarrell Reilly Homes Limited and Alcove Ireland Eight Ltd have been granted leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in a planning case against Meath County Council. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 28 March 2023.
Before the Meath County Development Plan 2021-2027 was adopted, all of the applicants' sites in County Meath were zoned Phase II New Residential (Post 2019). Under the new plan, one site was zoned for new residential development after 2027, while the rest were downzoned to less intensive uses.
The applicants challenged the rezoning in the High Court, where Humphreys J refused judicial review reliefs in a judgment on 1 July 2022. They argued that the council had not adopted a tiered approach in line with the National Planning Framework. They also said it was not consistent with the Regional Spatial and Economic Strategy. The judge held that the tiered approach applied only to lands already zoned for residential or economic activity under the previous plan.
Humphreys J also held that a challenge to the zoning of one piece of land, in isolation from the county's overall housing distribution, was not permissible. He said quashing the zoning would achieve nothing, because zoning those lands for housing would leave an excess of lands so zoned. He refused a certificate of leave to appeal.
The applicants asked the Supreme Court to hear an appeal on how the National Planning Framework and the Regional Spatial and Economic Strategy should be read. They also raised the duty to give reasons and address submissions in rezoning decisions, and the finding that a zoning decision cannot be challenged without challenging the plan's core strategy.
The panel of O'Donnell C.J., O'Malley J. and Hogan J. granted leave on the grounds set out in the application. It said the case raises points of law of general public importance. These concern the nature of a development plan and the grounds on which part of a plan can be challenged. The appeal will be listed with Killegland Estates' case for case management in early course.