localnews.ie

Brendan Kirwan granted Supreme Court appeal over delay ruling in property dispute

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

A five-judge panel said how courts apply the principles on dismissing delayed cases raises an issue of general public importance not recently examined.

Brendan Kirwan has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against the Court of Appeal's dismissal of his proceedings for delay. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 16 March 2023. The appeal will test how courts apply the principles on delay in bringing a case.

The dismissal ended his claims over a property transaction with Eamonn Buttle in July 2006. Mr Kirwan said Mr Buttle had agreed to buy certain lands from him, subject to planning permission, and to advance him approximately €1m. He also complained of a conflict of interest at the solicitors' firm MJ O'Connor Solicitors. The transaction did not proceed after the 2008 property crash.

The €1m debt was assigned to Filbeck Limited, of which Mr Buttle is a director. Filbeck obtained judgment against Mr Kirwan for some €1m in November 2012. Mr Kirwan brought his own actions, including a claim in August 2012 for some €3m against Mr Buttle and a plenary action in May 2013 against Mr Buttle, Filbeck and the solicitor defendants.

No steps were taken in the 2013 proceedings until Mr Buttle issued a motion on 17 August 2018 to have them dismissed for want of prosecution. In a reserved judgment on 2 September 2019, Meenan J struck out the proceedings for inordinate delay. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Power J with which Woulfe and Binchy JJ agreed, dismissed Mr Kirwan's appeal. It noted that he had done nothing to advance his claim for almost five years and that the delay had prejudiced the defendants.

Mr Kirwan, who represented himself, sought leave to appeal. The defendants said no stateable ground of appeal had been identified. They said he had not engaged with the findings of inordinate and inexcusable delay.

The five-judge panel of O'Donnell C.J., Charleton J., Hogan J., Murray J. and Collins J. said the Court of Appeal had applied the established Primor principles. It said how those principles should be applied, and whether they should be revised, is an issue the Supreme Court has not examined in recent times. It held that this raises an issue of general public importance. The court also noted that an ad hoc scheme of legal representation exists for personal litigants and invited Mr Kirwan to contact the Supreme Court Office within seven days.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal