Patrick Merlehan, trading as Ark Recycling, has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a waste case brought by Kildare County Council. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 24 February 2023.
On 15 March 2022 the High Court (Barr J) directed Mr Merlehan to stop the unauthorised holding, recovery and disposal of waste at lands at Moone, Co Kildare. The order followed a judgment delivered on 24 February 2022.
Mr Merlehan appealed, and the Court of Appeal heard the case on 15 November 2022. It declined to adjourn the appeal to await a High Court challenge he wished to bring on the constitutionality of the courts, because that issue had never been raised in the High Court. It found no merit in any ground of appeal and dismissed it.
Mr Merlehan asked the Supreme Court to hear an appeal, arguing that the Courts of Justice Act 1924 had never been commenced. He also relied on the interests of justice, sought a priority hearing and said a reference to the Court of Justice of the European Union might be needed. The council opposed leave.
The panel of Charleton J, Woulfe J and Collins J refused leave. It said the issues he raised had not been argued in the lower courts. It added that the points had been considered before by the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal and found to be without substance. It found that no question of a reference to the CJEU arose.