The Supreme Court on 17 January 2023 granted Séan Walsh leave to appeal directly from the High Court against an order for his surrender to the United Kingdom.
The Minister for Justice had sought Mr Walsh's surrender on a warrant issued under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement. On 24 October 2022 Mr Justice Biggs ordered that he be surrendered. Mr Walsh then applied to the Supreme Court, as no other appeal was open to him.
The High Court heard two objections. Mr Walsh said he faced a real risk of covert surveillance of his legal consultations and phone calls in prison. The judge was not satisfied that he had produced objective, reliable, specific and up-to-date information, or shown systemic deficiencies in the prison system of the issuing state.
The second objection concerned remission. Mr Walsh said that legislation now requires people convicted of terrorism offences to serve at least two thirds of their sentence, instead of half. He said that was a heavier penalty than applied at the time of the alleged offences. The Northern Ireland Court of Appeal had found the legislation incompatible with Article 7 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The High Court noted that he has not yet been sentenced.
The Minister opposed leave. The Minister said a change to remission does not engage Article 7, and that the issue is best dealt with in the issuing state, where an appeal on the legislation is pending before the UK Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Murray granted leave on whether it would breach Article 38 of the Constitution to return Mr Walsh to face charges arising from events in 2021, when the law on remission has changed in a way that may harm him. It said a matter of general public importance arises because the court has not decided that precise issue.
It also granted leave to argue the Article 7 question, while noting that ECHR issues are normally addressed in the requesting state's courts. A case management hearing will be held early on.