localnews.ie

Seamus Mallon granted Supreme Court appeal over sheriff retirement age of 70

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The sheriff for Cavan and Monaghan since 1987 is challenging the mandatory retirement age as incompatible with EU equality law.

Seamus Mallon, who was appointed sheriff for Cavan and Monaghan on 28 January 1987, has been granted leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 24 February 2023, in his challenge to the mandatory retirement age of 70 for sheriffs.

Section 12(6)(b) of the Court Officers Act 1945 sets the retirement age for the office of sheriff at 70. In July 2020 the Sheriffs' Association, of which Mr Mallon is a member, made a formal submission to the Minister for Justice seeking an amendment to that age. The Minister replied by email on 20 April 2021, citing the standard retirement age of 70 in the public service.

Mr Mallon began judicial review proceedings in July 2021. He sought to quash the Minister's decision not to review the age. He also sought a declaration that the law is incompatible with EU Council Directive 2000/78/EC on equal treatment in employment. He turned 70 in May 2022 and was obliged to retire.

Phelan J refused his application in the High Court on 6 October 2022. She held that the mandatory retirement age was discriminatory, but that the discrimination was justified by legitimate aims. These included planning for retirement and recruitment, making way for younger people, dignity, age balance and intergenerational fairness.

Mr Mallon then applied to the Supreme Court on 20 December 2022, saying there is no objective justification for the age. He also sought a priority hearing because the decision had removed him from active work in the public service. The Minister for Justice, Ireland and the Attorney General opposed. They said the grounds concern only a small number of sheriffs and raise no matter of general public importance. They also cross-appealed on whether the Minister's decision can be judicially reviewed.

The panel of Charleton J, Woulfe J and Collins J granted leave. It said the issues raise matters of general public importance likely to arise for other public service jobs with mandatory retirement ages. It said a direct appeal can be justified where there is an inevitability, or strong probability, of a case going to the Supreme Court, and that this case meets that requirement. The appeal will centre on four issues. These are whether section 12(6)(b) is compatible with the Directive, whether a compatibility test is needed and which factors count, whether limits can be set for defined groups rather than by individual assessment, and whether the Minister's decision not to amend the statute can be judicially reviewed.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal