Deirdre Little has been granted leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in a dispute over domiciliary care allowance for her son. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 20 February 2023, granting leave on two issues.
Ms Little applied for domiciliary care allowance for her minor son in 2018, and the application was refused because he was not a qualified child under section 186C of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005. Her appeal to an appeals officer failed, so she sought a revision of that decision under section 317 of the Act on the basis of new evidence. The revising appeals officer refused, because the new evidence did not show her son met the eligibility criteria when the claim was made.
Ms Little then brought judicial review proceedings, arguing that the revision power should be read broadly because the Act has a remedial purpose. Owens J rejected her arguments in the High Court on 8 December 2022, holding that eligibility is always referable to the time of the initial claim. He awarded costs against her, limited to the costs of a one-day hearing, although the hearing had taken two days.
Ms Little asked the Supreme Court to hear a direct appeal on that point and on the costs order. The Chief Appeals Officer, the Minister for Social Protection, Ireland and the Attorney General opposed leave. They said the High Court had applied well-established principles of statutory interpretation and that any appeal should go first to the Court of Appeal.
The panel of Charleton J, Woulfe J and Collins J found a matter of general public importance in the scope of the revision power under section 317. It said the issue is of very significant practical importance and could affect many applications under the Act. It also found exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal, noting that an intermediate appeal would delay a final answer and double the costs for Ms Little.
Leave was also granted on whether a court may consider an unsuccessful party's financial circumstances when deciding costs under section 169 of the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015. The court said that issue is ancillary to the main one. It added that Ms Little's request for a priority hearing would be met by allocating a date without delay once the appeal is ready.