localnews.ie

John O'Meara granted Supreme Court appeal over widow's and widower's pension

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court agreed to hear a direct appeal from the High Court on whether denying the pension to an unmarried partner and his children is lawful.

John O'Meara and his three children have been granted leave to bring an appeal directly to the Supreme Court. The decision was delivered on 20 February 2023. The appeal concerns the contributory pension paid to widows, widowers and surviving civil partners.

Mr O'Meara was the long-term partner of a woman who died in 2021. They had three minor children. The couple were not married and had not entered a civil partnership. Mr O'Meara is therefore neither a widower nor a surviving civil partner. He is not entitled to the pension under the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005.

The family challenged the law in the High Court. They argued that the pension rules are unconstitutional and breach the European Convention on Human Rights. Their main argument was that the law discriminates against children of unmarried parents. They said this was contrary to the equality guarantee in Article 40.1 of the Constitution. Heslin J dismissed their claim on 7 October 2022. He found the pension was not a benefit for a child. He also found that the distinction based on marital status rested on rational grounds. He said the aim was the support of marriage under Article 41 of the Constitution.

The family applied for leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court. The Minister for Social Protection, Ireland and the Attorney General opposed leave. They said the High Court had applied well-established principles. They said no issue of public importance arose.

The panel of Charleton J, Woulfe J and Collins J disagreed. It found that the appeal raises matters of general public importance. It also found exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal. The issues were unlikely to be narrowed by an appeal to the Court of Appeal. Imposing the costs of two appeals on the family would appear disproportionate.

Leave was granted on two issues. The first is whether non-payment of the pension is consistent with Articles 40.1 and 41 of the Constitution. The second is whether it is compatible with Article 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights, read with Article 8 and/or Article 1 of the First Protocol. The family also sought a priority hearing. The court said it would allocate a date without delay once the appeal is ready.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal