Shane Coffey has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a legal aid dispute. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 17 February 2023.
Mr Coffey faced three charges before the District Court from April 2015. A legal aid certificate covering all three charge sheets was granted on 28 April 2015.
His solicitor then asked for a new certificate for the charge brought by Garda O'Reilly. A District Judge said a signed certificate had already been received. Mr Coffey brought judicial review proceedings over that decision.
Meenan J in the High Court refused the relief he sought. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal and upheld that order on 25 February 2022.
Mr Coffey asked the Supreme Court to rule on his fair trial rights under Article 38.1 of the Constitution. He said those rights are not adequately protected where an accused lacks paid representation for each separate case. The respondents, a District Judge and the Minister for Justice and Equality, opposed leave. They said the Court of Appeal had applied established principles of law.
His application was made on 12 April 2022 and was not in time. The respondents did not oppose an extension of time. The panel of Dunne J, Charleton J and Collins J refused leave. It said an application could have been made to the first District Judge. Regulation 7(4) of the Criminal Justice (Legal Aid) Regulations 1965 could have allowed the court to direct separate certificates.